40  Origins of the Elements

40.1 Syllabus inquiry question

  • How do stars produce the elements found in the universe?
Feynman Insight

From The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol I, Chapter 3:

The atoms in your body—the calcium in your bones, the iron in your blood, the carbon in your DNA—were forged in the cores of stars that exploded billions of years ago. You are literally made of star stuff.

40.2 Learning Objectives

  • Explain the transformation of radiation to matter after the Big Bang
  • Apply Hubble’s law for universal expansion: \(v = H_0 d\)
  • Analyse stellar nucleosynthesis (proton-proton chain, CNO cycle)
  • Use stellar spectra to determine stellar properties
  • Interpret the H-R diagram for stellar classification and evolution

40.3 Content

40.3.1 The Big Bang and Early Universe

Timeline of the early universe:

Time Temperature Events
0 Big Bang singularity
10⁻⁴³ s 10³² K Planck era; physics unknown
10⁻³⁶ s 10²⁸ K Inflation; rapid expansion
10⁻⁶ s 10¹³ K Quarks combine into protons/neutrons
3 min 10⁹ K Nucleosynthesis: H, He, trace Li
380,000 yr 3000 K Recombination; CMB released
200 million yr ~100 K First stars form
Radiation to Matter

In the first seconds, the universe was so hot that photons spontaneously created particle-antiparticle pairs. As expansion cooled the universe, matter became stable. A tiny excess of matter over antimatter (~1 part in 10⁹) gave us the universe we see today.

40.3.2 Interactive: Early Universe Timeline

40.3.3 Hubble’s Law

Edwin Hubble (1929) discovered that galaxies are receding from us, with velocity proportional to distance:

\[v = H_0 d\]

where: - \(v\) = recession velocity (km/s or m/s) - \(H_0\) = Hubble constant ≈ 70 km/s/Mpc ≈ 2.3 × 10⁻¹⁸ s⁻¹ - \(d\) = distance to galaxy

Age of the Universe

The Hubble constant gives an estimate of the age of the universe: \[t \approx 1/H_0 \approx 13.8\ \text{billion years}\]

40.3.4 Evidence for Expansion: Redshift

Cosmological redshift: As space expands, wavelengths of light stretch:

\[z = \frac{\lambda_{observed} - \lambda_{emitted}}{\lambda_{emitted}} = \frac{v}{c}\]

For non-relativistic speeds (v << c): \[v = cz\]

40.3.5 Interactive: Redshift and Distance

40.3.6 Black Body Radiation and Stars

Stars approximate black bodies—their spectrum depends only on temperature.

Wien’s displacement law: \[\lambda_{max} = \frac{b}{T}\]

where \(b = 2.90 \times 10^{-3}\) m·K

Surface Temp Peak λ Star Colour Example
3000 K 967 nm Red Betelgeuse
5800 K 500 nm Yellow Sun
10000 K 290 nm Blue-white Vega
30000 K 97 nm Blue Rigel

40.3.7 Interactive: Black Body Spectrum

40.3.8 Stellar Spectra Classification

Stars are classified by spectral type (temperature):

Type Temperature Colour Features
O 30,000-50,000 K Blue Ionised He lines
B 10,000-30,000 K Blue-white Neutral He lines
A 7,500-10,000 K White Strong H lines
F 6,000-7,500 K Yellow-white Weak H, ionised metals
G 5,200-6,000 K Yellow Solar-type; Ca lines
K 3,700-5,200 K Orange Neutral metals
M 2,400-3,700 K Red Molecular bands (TiO)
Mnemonic

Oh Be A Fine Girl/Guy, Kiss Me”

40.3.9 Absorption Spectra

Dark lines in stellar spectra reveal: - Composition: Which elements are in the star’s atmosphere - Temperature: Which spectral lines are strongest - Radial velocity: Doppler shift of lines - Magnetic fields: Zeeman splitting of lines

40.3.10 The H-R Diagram

The Hertzsprung-Russell diagram plots luminosity vs temperature:

40.3.11 Interactive: H-R Diagram

Key regions:

Region Location Characteristics
Main sequence Diagonal band Hydrogen fusion; stable
Red giants Upper right He fusion; expanded envelope
Supergiants Top Massive; short-lived
White dwarfs Lower left Stellar remnants; no fusion

40.3.12 Stellar Evolution

Initial Mass Main Sequence Life End State
< 0.5 M☉ > 100 billion years White dwarf
0.5-8 M☉ 100 million - 10 billion years White dwarf
8-25 M☉ 10-100 million years Neutron star
> 25 M☉ < 10 million years Black hole

40.3.13 Nucleosynthesis: Where Elements Come From

Process Location Elements Produced
Big Bang Early universe H, He, trace Li
Proton-proton chain Main sequence (low mass) He from H
CNO cycle Main sequence (high mass) He from H
Triple-alpha Red giants C from He
Alpha capture Giants O, Ne, Mg, Si
Silicon burning Massive star cores Up to Fe
Supernova Stellar explosion Elements > Fe
Neutron star mergers Compact object collision Heavy r-process elements

40.3.14 Interactive: Element Origins

40.3.15 The Proton-Proton Chain

The main energy source in Sun-like stars:

Overall reaction: \[4^1_1\text{H} \rightarrow ^4_2\text{He} + 2e^+ + 2\nu_e + 26.7\ \text{MeV}\]

Steps: 1. \(^1\text{H} + ^1\text{H} \rightarrow ^2\text{H} + e^+ + \nu_e\) (slow; rate-limiting) 2. \(^2\text{H} + ^1\text{H} \rightarrow ^3\text{He} + \gamma\) 3. \(^3\text{He} + ^3\text{He} \rightarrow ^4\text{He} + 2^1\text{H}\)

40.3.16 The CNO Cycle

Dominates in stars > 1.3 M☉ (higher temperature needed):

Overall reaction: Same as pp-chain \[4^1_1\text{H} \rightarrow ^4_2\text{He} + 2e^+ + 2\nu_e + 26.7\ \text{MeV}\]

Key difference: Uses C, N, O as catalysts; faster at high temperatures

Iron: The End of Fusion

Fusion releases energy only up to iron (Fe-56). Iron has the highest binding energy per nucleon. Fusing heavier elements requires energy input—this only happens in supernovae.

40.4 Worked Examples

40.4.1 Example 1: Hubble’s law

A galaxy is 50 Mpc away. Calculate its recession velocity. (H₀ = 70 km/s/Mpc)

Solution:

  1. Use \(v = H_0 d\)

  2. \(v = 70 \times 50 = 3500\) km/s

40.4.2 Example 2: Redshift to velocity

A spectral line normally at 656.3 nm is observed at 659.6 nm. Calculate the galaxy’s recession velocity.

Solution:

  1. \(\Delta\lambda = 659.6 - 656.3 = 3.3\) nm

  2. \(z = \Delta\lambda/\lambda = 3.3/656.3 = 0.00503\)

  3. \(v = cz = 3.0 \times 10^8 \times 0.00503 = 1.5 \times 10^6\) m/s = 1500 km/s

40.4.3 Example 3: Wien’s law for a star

A star has peak emission at 400 nm. Calculate its surface temperature.

Solution:

  1. Use \(\lambda_{max} = b/T\)

  2. \(T = b/\lambda_{max} = (2.90 \times 10^{-3})/(4.0 \times 10^{-7})\)

  3. \(T = 7250\) K (A-type star, white)

40.4.4 Example 4: Energy from pp-chain

The Sun converts 6.0 × 10¹¹ kg of hydrogen to helium each second. Calculate the power output.

Solution:

  1. Mass defect per 4H → He: \(\Delta m = 4(1.0078) - 4.0026 = 0.0286\) u

  2. Fraction converted: \(0.0286/4.0312 = 0.71\%\)

  3. Mass converted per second: \(6.0 \times 10^{11} \times 0.0071 = 4.3 \times 10^9\) kg

  4. \(E = mc^2 = 4.3 \times 10^9 \times (3.0 \times 10^8)^2 = 3.9 \times 10^{26}\) W

40.4.5 Example 5: Distance from redshift

A quasar has redshift z = 0.2. Estimate its distance. (H₀ = 70 km/s/Mpc)

Solution:

  1. \(v = cz = 3.0 \times 10^5 \times 0.2 = 6.0 \times 10^4\) km/s

  2. \(d = v/H_0 = 60000/70 = 857\) Mpc

  3. \(d = 857 \times 3.26 = 2800\) million light-years ≈ 2.8 billion light-years

40.5 Common Misconceptions

Common Misconceptions
  • Misconception: The Big Bang was an explosion in space. Correction: The Big Bang was the expansion of space itself. There’s no “centre” or external space it expanded into.

  • Misconception: Redshift is just the Doppler effect. Correction: Cosmological redshift is due to space expanding, not motion through space. Very distant galaxies have redshifts corresponding to “velocities” greater than c.

  • Misconception: Hotter stars are always brighter. Correction: Brightness depends on both temperature AND size. A cool red giant can be brighter than a hot white dwarf because it’s much larger.

  • Misconception: The Sun produces energy by burning hydrogen like a fire. Correction: The Sun fuses hydrogen into helium—a nuclear reaction, not chemical burning. Nuclear fusion releases millions of times more energy per kg.

  • Misconception: All elements were made in the Big Bang. Correction: The Big Bang only made H, He, and traces of Li. All heavier elements (carbon, oxygen, iron, gold…) were made in stars.

40.6 Practice Questions

40.6.1 Easy (2 marks)

Use Wien’s law to calculate the peak wavelength emitted by a star with surface temperature 4000 K.

  • Use \(\lambda_{max} = b/T\) (1)
  • \(\lambda_{max} = (2.90 \times 10^{-3})/4000 = 7.25 \times 10^{-7}\) m = 725 nm (1)

Answer: λ_max = 725 nm (infrared/red)

40.6.2 Medium (4 marks)

A galaxy shows a hydrogen line shifted from 656.3 nm to 658.0 nm. Calculate the recession velocity and the distance to the galaxy (H₀ = 70 km/s/Mpc).

  • \(\Delta\lambda = 658.0 - 656.3 = 1.7\) nm (1)
  • \(v = c \times \Delta\lambda/\lambda = 3.0 \times 10^8 \times 1.7/656.3 = 7.8 \times 10^5\) m/s = 780 km/s (1)
  • \(d = v/H_0 = 780/70 = 11.1\) Mpc (1)
  • Convert: \(11.1 \times 3.26 = 36\) million light-years (1)

Answer: v = 780 km/s; d = 11 Mpc ≈ 36 million light-years

40.6.3 Hard (5 marks)

Compare two stars on the H-R diagram: Star A (10,000 K, luminosity 100 L☉) and Star B (5000 K, luminosity 100 L☉). Explain which star is larger and in what evolutionary stage each might be.

  • Luminosity depends on T⁴ and R²: L ∝ R²T⁴ (1)
  • Same luminosity but Star B cooler → Star B must be larger (1)
  • Star A: main sequence (hot, moderate luminosity for temperature) (1)
  • Star B: giant or subgiant (cool but high luminosity → expanded) (1)
  • Star B has R²/R² ∝ (10000/5000)⁴ = 16× larger radius (1)

Answer: Star B is 4× larger in radius. Star A is likely main sequence; Star B is a red giant (cooler but same luminosity requires larger surface area).

40.7 Multiple Choice Questions

Test your understanding with these interactive questions:

40.8 Summary

Key Takeaways
  • Big Bang created H, He, trace Li; heavier elements made in stars
  • Hubble’s law: \(v = H_0 d\) (expansion of the universe)
  • Wien’s law: \(\lambda_{max} = b/T\) (stellar temperature from colour)
  • H-R diagram: luminosity vs temperature classification
  • Main sequence: hydrogen fusion (pp-chain or CNO)
  • Supernovae: produce elements heavier than iron
  • Spectral types: O B A F G K M (hot to cool)

40.9 Self-Assessment

Check your understanding:

After studying this section, you should be able to:

40.10 Module 8 Complete

Congratulations on completing Module 8: From the Universe to the Atom!

What you’ve learned
  • Atomic structure: Thomson, Rutherford, Millikan, Chadwick experiments
  • Quantum mechanics: Bohr model, de Broglie waves, Schrödinger’s equation
  • Nuclear physics: radioactive decay, binding energy, fission and fusion
  • Particle physics: Standard Model, quarks, leptons, accelerators
  • Astrophysics: Big Bang, stellar spectra, nucleosynthesis, H-R diagram
Course Complete

You have now completed all 8 modules of the NSW HSC Physics course. This journey has taken you from the fundamental forces and motion of Module 1 through to the origins of the elements in the cosmos. Physics is a unified discipline—the same laws that govern atoms also govern stars. Keep questioning, keep exploring.