7  Relative Motion

7.1 Syllabus inquiry question

  • How is the motion of an object moving in a straight line described and predicted?
Feynman Insight

From The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol I, Chapter 15:

Motion is always measured relative to a chosen frame. Changing the frame changes the numbers, but it does not change the physics.

7.2 Learning Objectives

  • Define relative position and relative velocity.
  • Solve one-dimensional relative motion problems.
  • Apply vector subtraction to two-dimensional relative motion.
  • Interpret motion from different reference frames.

7.3 Content

7.3.1 Relative velocity in one dimension

Relative velocity compares two objects moving along the same line:

\[v_{AB} = v_A - v_B\]

This reads as “the velocity of A relative to B”.

Subscript notation

\(v_{AB}\) means “velocity of A as observed from B” or “velocity of A relative to B”

7.3.2 Interactive: One-Dimensional Relative Motion

Consider two cars on a highway. Their relative velocity determines how quickly the gap between them changes.

Example: Car A at 25 m/s, Car B at 18 m/s (both east)

  • Relative velocity: \(v_{AB} = 25 - 18 = 7\) m/s
  • Car A approaches Car B at 7 m/s

7.3.3 Relative velocity in two dimensions

Vectors are subtracted component-wise. The relative velocity points from the observer to the object being described.

\[\vec{v}_{AB} = \vec{v}_A - \vec{v}_B\]

7.3.4 Interactive: Boat and River Current

A classic relative motion problem: a boat crossing a river with current.

Interpreting the diagram:

  • Blue vector: boat’s velocity relative to water (heading north)
  • Green vector: water’s velocity relative to ground (current flowing east)
  • Red dashed vector: boat’s velocity relative to ground (resultant)

7.3.5 Reference frames

A statement about motion is incomplete without a frame. The same motion can be described differently in different frames without contradiction.

Frame of Reference

All velocity measurements require specifying:

  1. What is moving
  2. Relative to what it’s being measured

7.3.6 Common Relative Motion Scenarios

Scenario Frame A Frame B Relative Velocity
Overtaking cars Ground Slower car Difference in speeds
Boat in current Water Ground Vector sum
Rain on cyclist Ground Cyclist Vector difference
Aircraft in wind Air Ground Vector sum

7.4 Worked Examples

7.4.1 Example 1: Overtaking cars

Car A travels at 25 m/s east. Car B travels at 18 m/s east. Find A relative to B.

Solution:

  1. \(v_{AB} = v_A - v_B = 25 - 18 = 7\) m/s
  2. The positive result indicates A moves east relative to B
  3. A closes the gap at 7 m/s

7.4.2 Example 2: Boat and current

A boat heads due north at 4.0 m/s relative to the water. The current is 1.5 m/s east. Find velocity relative to the ground.

Solution:

  1. Components: \(v_x = 1.5\) m/s, \(v_y = 4.0\) m/s
  2. Speed: \(\sqrt{1.5^2 + 4.0^2} = \sqrt{18.25} = 4.3\) m/s
  3. Direction: \(\tan^{-1}(1.5/4.0) = 20°\) east of north

7.4.3 Example 3: Rain and a moving cyclist

Rain falls vertically at 6.0 m/s. A cyclist rides east at 5.0 m/s. Find the rain velocity relative to the cyclist.

Solution:

The rain’s velocity relative to the cyclist is found by vector subtraction:

\[\vec{v}_{rain/cyclist} = \vec{v}_{rain} - \vec{v}_{cyclist}\]

  1. Rain (relative to ground): \(v_x = 0\), \(v_y = -6.0\) m/s (downward)
  2. Cyclist (relative to ground): \(v_x = 5.0\) m/s, \(v_y = 0\)
  3. Rain relative to cyclist: \(v_x = 0 - 5.0 = -5.0\) m/s, \(v_y = -6.0\) m/s

Result: - Speed: \(\sqrt{5.0^2 + 6.0^2} = 7.8\) m/s - Direction: \(\tan^{-1}(5.0/6.0) = 40°\) from vertical, toward the cyclist (west of vertical)

Tip

The rain appears to come from ahead! This is why cyclists lean forward in rain.

7.4.4 Example 4: Head-on collision approach

Two trains approach each other. Train A travels at 30 m/s east, Train B at 25 m/s west.

Solution:

Taking east as positive: - \(v_A = +30\) m/s - \(v_B = -25\) m/s

Relative velocity: - \(v_{AB} = v_A - v_B = 30 - (-25) = 55\) m/s

The trains approach each other at the sum of their speeds.

7.4.5 Interactive: Aircraft Navigation

An aircraft must aim off-course to compensate for wind:

Navigation problem: To fly due north (90°), the pilot must aim slightly west to compensate for the eastward wind.

7.5 Common Misconceptions

Common Misconceptions
  • Misconception: Relative velocity adds magnitudes. Correction: It is a vector difference; direction matters.

  • Misconception: The faster object always has a positive relative velocity. Correction: The sign depends on the chosen frame and direction convention.

  • Misconception: Reference frames change the laws of motion. Correction: They change measurements, not the laws.

  • Misconception: Objects moving in the same direction have zero relative velocity. Correction: Only if they have the same speed in the same direction.

7.6 Practice Questions

7.6.1 Easy (2 marks)

A bus moves at 12 m/s east. A passenger walks at 1.5 m/s east relative to the bus. Find the passenger’s speed relative to the ground.

  • Correct relative velocity model (1)
  • Correct final speed with units (1)

Answer: \(v_{pg} = v_{pb} + v_{bg} = 1.5 + 12 = 13.5\) m/s east

7.6.2 Medium (4 marks)

A swimmer aims straight across a river at 1.8 m/s relative to the water. The current flows 1.2 m/s downstream. Find the swimmer’s ground velocity and direction.

  • Correct vector addition (2)
  • Correct speed and direction (2)

Answer: - \(v_x = 1.2\) m/s (downstream), \(v_y = 1.8\) m/s (across) - Speed: \(\sqrt{1.2^2 + 1.8^2} = 2.2\) m/s - Direction: \(\tan^{-1}(1.2/1.8) = 34°\) downstream from straight across

7.6.3 Hard (5 marks)

Plane A flies 250 km/h north. Plane B flies 180 km/h east. Determine the velocity of A relative to B.

  • Correct vector subtraction setup (2)
  • Correct relative speed (2)
  • Correct direction description (1)

Solution:

\(\vec{v}_{AB} = \vec{v}_A - \vec{v}_B\)

Components: - \(v_{AB,x} = 0 - 180 = -180\) km/h (west) - \(v_{AB,y} = 250 - 0 = 250\) km/h (north)

Relative speed: - \(v_{AB} = \sqrt{180^2 + 250^2} = \sqrt{94900} = 308\) km/h

Direction: - \(\theta = \tan^{-1}(180/250) = 36°\) west of north

Answer: 308 km/h at 36° west of north

From B’s perspective, A appears to move northwest.

7.7 Multiple Choice Questions

Test your understanding with these interactive questions:

7.8 Summary

Key Takeaways
  • Relative motion compares objects using a chosen frame.
  • One-dimensional problems use signed subtraction.
  • Two-dimensional problems require vector subtraction.
  • Clear frame statements prevent sign and direction errors.

7.9 Self-Assessment

Check your understanding:

After studying this section, you should be able to:

7.10 Module 1 Complete

Congratulations on completing Module 1: Kinematics!

What you’ve learned
  • Motion in a straight line (displacement, velocity, acceleration)
  • Graphical analysis of motion
  • SUVAT equations for constant acceleration
  • Vector operations in two dimensions
  • Relative motion between objects